January Baking Challenge

This Sallyโ€™s Baking Challenge Has Ended

Visit the Sallyโ€™s Baking Challenge page for FAQs and all the previous challenge recipes.


Letโ€™s Review the December Baking Challenge

December 2021 Sallyโ€™s Baking Challenge Recipe: Wedge Shortbread Cookies

If your December wasnโ€™t already filled with cookies, do yourself a scrolling favor and look at all the buttery goodness below. Decemberโ€™s challenge gave participants a shortbread dough recipe and the opportunity to add fun flavors, add-ins, and toppings as well as bake the cookies in different pans. Though I assigned an easy recipe, the creative freedom was fun and expansive! Some my team and I enjoyed seeing were: salted caramel shortbread, shortbread baked in small 6-inch pans for mini wedge โ€œbitesโ€, cranberry & dark chocolate, lemon rosemary, wedges decorated as Rudolph, and white chocolate coconut & lime shortbread. WOW!

Thank you so much for participating! We gathered as many shortbread cookies emailed photo entries as we could and included them below.

December Baking Challenge Winner

Challenge winner for December is Kathryn who has already been notified.

December 2021 Baking Challenge Winner Image

Want to Save This Recipe?

Enter your email below, and weโ€™ll send the link straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll join 250,000 fellow bakers and receive my trusted baking recipes each week!

    We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Join Sally's Baking Challenge

    This recipe was a baking challenge! On the 1st of every month, I publish a new Sallyโ€™s Baking Challenge recipe. By subscribing below, youโ€™ll receive a welcome email detailing the monthly challenges and how to win, plus all of the challenge recipes and updates as theyโ€™re published.

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

      sally mckenney headshot purple shirt.
      About the Author

      Sally McKenney

      Sally McKenney is a professional baker, food photographer, and cookbook author. Since 2011, she has been sharing meticulously tested recipes and step-by-step tutorials, helping home bakers gain confidence in the kitchen. Over the years, her dedication to approachable baking has built a loyal community of millions. Her work has been featured on Good Morning America, in People Magazine, and on popular sites like BuzzFeed, HuffPost, The Kitchn, and Country Living.

      Read More

      Leave a Comment

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

      Reader Comments and Reviews

      1. Gretchen says:
        January 31, 2022

        I really enjoyed making these and learning something new. I found they browned too quickly (a little burnt ) next time I make them Iโ€™ll put my gas low it might be better. They were delicious. Thank you.

        Reply
      2. Chelsea F. says:
        January 25, 2022

        I enjoyed this challenge and look forward to next month!

        Reply
      3. Marilyn says:
        January 22, 2022

        This was a good challenge to try baking something I had never made before. We generally eat English muffins but not whole wheat ones. I would like to try making them again using just the white flour.

        Reply
      4. Melanie says:
        January 19, 2022

        I thought we would have extra to freeze but these are definitely not going to make it that long! First time making English muffins and they are great- so much better than store bought. Chewy, wheaty (but not too dense), soft. The more I keep eating them the more I love them.

        Reply
      5. Margaret Horvath says:
        January 18, 2022

        The Honey Whole Wheat English muffins are delicious and so easy to make!! My family loved them.

        Reply
      6. Robert Acker says:
        January 6, 2022

        I really donโ€™t get it! After all the decorating and imagination bakers created, the choice of the Shortbread Cookie winner of the December Baking Challenge had no personality, no flare and whereโ€™s the Holiday spirit!
        Thank you.

        Reply
        1. Sally @ Sally's Baking says:
          January 7, 2022

          Hi Robert, the monthly challenges are not contestsโ€“ they are just a fun giveaway requiring participation. The winner is randomly selected using a number generator tool and not based on a photoโ€™s appearance.

          Reply
      7. Michelle says:
        January 2, 2022

        Congratulations to Kathryn! Your shortbread looks scrumptious. Love seeing the variety in everyoneโ€™s creations!

        Reply
      8. Laura says:
        January 1, 2022

        Congratulations, Kathryn! Looks delicious!

        Reply
      9. Sasha says:
        January 1, 2022

        I have a feeling this is going to be my new go to breakfast. So excited to try. Thanks for a great sounding recipe to start of my 2022 baking on an amazing not. Your the best Sally! Have a great 2022 everyone!

        Reply
        1. Sasha says:
          January 1, 2022

          oops meant note not not

          Reply
      10. Nora Bernier says:
        January 1, 2022

        Congratulations Kathryn. What a way to start the new year

        Reply